1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:11,020
So let me, first of all, welcome you virtually to the DEF CON Ethics Village and introduce you briefly to those who will be watching.

2
00:00:11,020 --> 00:00:16,500
This is FCC Commissioner Jeffrey Starks.

3
00:00:16,500 --> 00:00:24,470
Commissioner Starks was sworn in as an FCC Commissioner on January 30th of 2019.

4
00:00:24,870 --> 00:00:37,370
He had previous experience at the FCC, helping to lead efforts in the FCC's Enforcement Bureau by, among other things, handling a number of complex investigations.

5
00:00:37,370 --> 00:00:48,890
He also has prior Department of Justice experience as a Senior Advisor to the Deputy Attorney General on a variety of domestic and international matters.

6
00:00:48,890 --> 00:00:52,230
And this was all during the Obama Administration.

7
00:00:52,330 --> 00:01:09,770
And before Commissioner Starks entered federal public service, he practiced law at Williams and Connolly, clerked on the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, and also served as a legislative staffer in the Illinois State Senate and worked as a financial analyst.

8
00:01:09,770 --> 00:01:13,810
So thank you again for your time, Commissioner Starks.

9
00:01:13,810 --> 00:01:16,650
Let me just briefly say my name is Stephanie Pell.

10
00:01:16,650 --> 00:01:18,550
I'm a professor at West Point.

11
00:01:18,550 --> 00:01:37,110
And because I work at West Point, I'm always required to say whenever I open my mouth in public that even though this is about you, we're going to be talking about your views, anything that should come out of my mouth are my views and do not represent the views of West Point,

12
00:01:37,110 --> 00:01:40,210
the Army, or certainly the United States government.

13
00:01:40,750 --> 00:01:46,090
So let me just start with an opening question, Commissioner Starks.

14
00:01:46,090 --> 00:02:01,590
For those who may not be terribly familiar with the FCC, could you give us some brief background about its structure and mandate, specifically in reference to the issues we will discuss today?

15
00:02:02,050 --> 00:02:02,430
Yes.

16
00:02:02,430 --> 00:02:06,030
Well, as always, great to be in dialogue with you, Stephanie.

17
00:02:06,030 --> 00:02:13,790
Glad to be joining DEF CON 2020, obviously virtually here this year in the ethics village in particular.

18
00:02:14,450 --> 00:02:29,550
And so for viewers who might not be familiar with the FCC, it's an independent federal agency established back in 1934 under the Communications Act, and we're charged with, you know, regulating interstate and foreign communications by radio, television,

19
00:02:29,550 --> 00:02:32,590
wire, satellite, and cable.

20
00:02:32,830 --> 00:02:38,950
And so to the structure of the commission, it's directed by five commissioners, including myself.

21
00:02:38,950 --> 00:02:43,710
Each commissioner is appointed by the president, subject to Senate confirmation.

22
00:02:44,010 --> 00:02:55,350
And because we're an independent agency, only three commissioners can be of the same political party, the president obviously designating one commissioner as the chairperson.

23
00:02:55,350 --> 00:03:10,190
You know, and to the breadth that we serve, we have seven bureaus, 10 offices of career civil servants for the most part, senior engineers, economists, obviously a lot of this is wrapped up in their expertise and experience with communications.

24
00:03:10,190 --> 00:03:20,270
And so Congress has given us significant and specific responsibilities, but broadly we are regulating the nation's communication networks.

25
00:03:20,270 --> 00:03:39,970
And so that includes, you know, promoting deployment of advanced communication services like broadband, like we're going to talk about, ensuring best and highest use of wireless spectrum, administering the universal service fund, which is a fund that ensures access to modern communications for the low income,

26
00:03:39,970 --> 00:03:46,290
for rural folks, for schools, libraries, regulating foreign access to U.S.

27
00:03:46,350 --> 00:03:48,030
communications marketplace.

28
00:03:48,030 --> 00:03:50,170
We may get into some of that a little bit later.

29
00:03:50,820 --> 00:03:56,650
And then finally, you know, what folks would think of regulating radio and broadcast television.

30
00:03:56,650 --> 00:04:09,350
So the last thing I'd kind of focus on rounding this out is, you know, because communications is such a broad term, you know, some folks may think that we have certain authority that really isn't us.

31
00:04:09,350 --> 00:04:17,630
And so when people think about who regulates Facebook, that is a lot of other people, Department of Justice, the FTC.

32
00:04:18,350 --> 00:04:22,130
And so, you know, there are a lot of things that we do.

33
00:04:22,130 --> 00:04:30,470
And then we obviously, you know, there are things that we have jurisdiction over, but other folks have other points.

34
00:04:30,610 --> 00:04:44,870
And then if you have followed the issue of network neutrality, you know, there is obviously, you know, some fluidity between administrations on what is the extent of the FCC's authority and what's within our jurisdiction.

35
00:04:44,870 --> 00:04:53,910
I think we do have authority to enforce network neutrality rules, but some of my, in particular, Republican majority of the FCC disagrees with me.

36
00:04:53,910 --> 00:04:58,170
So that's kind of a little bit of the lay of the land, as it were.

37
00:04:58,810 --> 00:04:59,530
Thanks.

38
00:04:59,530 --> 00:05:09,670
So as you acknowledged, in more normal times, we would be, you know, meeting in person, having this discussion live in Vegas.

39
00:05:09,870 --> 00:05:12,130
So we're not doing that now.

40
00:05:12,130 --> 00:05:26,430
We've all had to adapt in a number of ways, moving significant portions of our lives online, including work for those who have college or school age children.

41
00:05:26,430 --> 00:05:33,570
You know, a good portion, if not all of their education, has suddenly become virtual.

42
00:05:33,670 --> 00:05:43,390
So I'm wondering, how has your focus at the FCC and your work changed since the beginning of COVID?

43
00:05:43,750 --> 00:05:45,730
Yeah, it's a great question.

44
00:05:45,730 --> 00:05:51,810
You know, in some ways, through a certain lens, you know, the Commission has continued its work.

45
00:05:51,810 --> 00:05:54,690
We have all been working remotely since March.

46
00:05:54,690 --> 00:06:05,650
And we have had, as we're required by statute, we've had monthly open meetings, and we're voting items, and we are proceeding with our work apace.

47
00:06:06,510 --> 00:06:18,270
You know, but in a lot of other ways, in particular, the issue of digital divide, and who has broadband access and who doesn't, has been my top priority.

48
00:06:18,270 --> 00:06:21,490
But that really has been amplified in a lot of ways.

49
00:06:21,490 --> 00:06:38,870
The last few months have laid bare the already cruel reality of the digital divide, that millions and millions, tens of millions of Americans don't access, cannot afford broadband connections that they need to telework, to access telemedicine now, to help young people learn,

50
00:06:38,870 --> 00:06:40,110
as you mentioned.

51
00:06:40,110 --> 00:06:44,530
And addressing this long-running crisis has never been more urgent.

52
00:06:44,530 --> 00:06:56,730
When public health requires social distancing, even quarantining, as many of us have been doing, closing the digital divide has become central to our safety, and certainly it's powering our economy.

53
00:06:56,830 --> 00:07:06,250
And so, you know, a number of weeks into the crisis, in early March, I published an op-ed in the New York Times calling for a connectivity stimulus.

54
00:07:06,370 --> 00:07:13,870
We obviously have a lot of ways where we're talking about stimulus for public health, for our economy.

55
00:07:13,870 --> 00:07:26,170
I think we need a connectivity stimulus, because regulators, industry, we have to, and need to even now more so than ever, dramatically expand access for broadband during this emergency.

56
00:07:26,170 --> 00:07:30,830
Some of those ideas that I laid out initially in March have been implemented.

57
00:07:30,830 --> 00:07:37,110
We are leaning into the flexible use of wireless spectrum that's underutilized.

58
00:07:37,110 --> 00:07:45,230
Broadband providers have joined the fight, waiving some data caps, the Keep America Connected pledge, opening Wi-Fi networks.

59
00:07:45,230 --> 00:07:48,790
But really, truth be told, Stephanie, it hasn't been enough.

60
00:07:48,790 --> 00:07:51,590
And I have called for us to do more.

61
00:07:51,930 --> 00:08:12,250
We are... And speaking, if I can just, speaking of doing more, I want to specifically reference a recent, an additional op-ed, a recent one that you co-authored with a number of prominent civil rights leaders, the Reverend Al Sharpton, Venita Gupta, Morial,

62
00:08:12,250 --> 00:08:14,170
and Morita Coley.

63
00:08:14,170 --> 00:08:25,170
And the op-ed, for those who haven't seen it, is entitled, Broadband Access is a Civil Right We Can't Afford to Lose, But Many Can't Afford to Have.

64
00:08:25,630 --> 00:08:35,230
In that piece, you and your co-authors speak directly to how COVID-19 has exposed this digital divide.

65
00:08:35,490 --> 00:08:42,250
And could you talk more about the scope of that digital divide problem?

66
00:08:42,250 --> 00:08:44,950
Yeah, happy to.

67
00:08:44,950 --> 00:08:53,770
And like I said, the digital divide was present even before COVID-19, but it has really been exacerbated.

68
00:08:53,810 --> 00:08:55,870
And I wanted to emphasize that.

69
00:08:55,870 --> 00:09:08,590
The fact of the matter is that the late John Lewis, one of my heroes, said that internet access is the civil rights issue of the 21st century.

70
00:09:08,590 --> 00:09:10,530
And I agree.

71
00:09:11,850 --> 00:09:25,710
The Communication Act instructs us to make communication service available to all Americans without discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, or sex.

72
00:09:25,950 --> 00:09:34,830
And so civil rights leaders have long held government accountable where we have unfulfilled promises.

73
00:09:34,930 --> 00:09:46,970
And so closing this digital divide, I was honored, deeply honored, to join some of those civil rights leaders talking about how, in particular, with communities of color, we need to close the digital divide.

74
00:09:46,970 --> 00:10:05,100
As we outlined in the op-ed, 34% of African Americans, 39% of Latino adults, 47% of tribal groups all lack access to broadband connection, significantly, disproportionately less so than their white counterparts.

75
00:10:05,550 --> 00:10:13,630
And so when you're talking about civil rights issues, we have to have it access ubiquitous for all.

76
00:10:13,630 --> 00:10:15,230
And it has to be right now.

77
00:10:15,230 --> 00:10:22,250
There needs to be a fierce urgency of now that we solve these digital divide issues.

78
00:10:22,250 --> 00:10:32,270
And for communities of color, that means reliable and convenient access to educational resources, to workplace materials, telemedicine, like I said.

79
00:10:32,270 --> 00:10:43,210
You know, the fact of the matter is that we have... this is a rural issue in some ways, making sure that folks get access everywhere.

80
00:10:43,210 --> 00:10:55,910
But the fact of the matter is that we've seen this as well throughout the pandemic, that in densely, highly populated urban areas, there are nearly three times as many households that remain unconnected.

81
00:10:55,910 --> 00:10:58,950
And that is frequently communities of color.

82
00:10:58,950 --> 00:11:06,730
Over 18 million households lack broadband simply, solely, research estimates, because it's too expensive.

83
00:11:06,750 --> 00:11:19,550
And so one of the things that I've called for, and have worked with Congress on, is that for both the emergency and for the longer term, we need to have a more affordable connection for millions of Americans to the internet.

84
00:11:19,550 --> 00:11:23,750
We know 50 million-plus Americans have filed for unemployment assistance.

85
00:11:23,870 --> 00:11:29,610
And so making sure there is an affordable way that they can connect to high-quality broadband is going to be important.

86
00:11:29,630 --> 00:11:33,130
Something else that I would talk on really quickly here is the Lifeline program.

87
00:11:33,130 --> 00:11:42,090
It's the federal program specifically designed to provide free or discounted telecom service to low-income Americans.

88
00:11:42,090 --> 00:11:45,630
We know that this program is grossly underutilized.

89
00:11:45,630 --> 00:11:52,430
About seven and a half million Americans are on Lifeline right now, despite over 38 million being eligible.

90
00:11:52,430 --> 00:12:01,390
And so we have got to make sure, for example, we know that more Americans are on food assistance, on SNAP, right now than ever.

91
00:12:01,390 --> 00:12:07,410
And if you have food insecurity issues, you probably also have digital insecurity issues.

92
00:12:07,410 --> 00:12:12,130
So I've called for us to better coordinate with USDA that runs SNAP.

93
00:12:12,130 --> 00:12:18,150
If you are knocking on the door for help there, we should also make sure that you get connected to the Lifeline program.

94
00:12:18,150 --> 00:12:24,150
And so there's a lot of ways that we need to make sure that our government is not working in silos right now.

95
00:12:24,150 --> 00:12:26,110
And I think that's really important.

96
00:12:26,330 --> 00:12:26,770
Sure.

97
00:12:26,770 --> 00:12:36,630
So these are... you've just listed some very specific prescriptions that you and others in the civil rights community have called for.

98
00:12:36,630 --> 00:12:39,690
How supportive, in your view, is Congress being?

99
00:12:39,690 --> 00:12:41,510
What can they do?

100
00:12:42,030 --> 00:12:49,890
Yeah, you know, I think in particular, obviously, we are seeing that there is a new COVID...

101
00:12:50,630 --> 00:12:55,490
I think it's the fifth part of the package that's being negotiated right now.

102
00:12:55,570 --> 00:13:01,110
Broadband has still, to date, not been included in some of those congressional packages.

103
00:13:01,110 --> 00:13:07,310
And so providing more money for E-Rate, another program that we have to provide money to schools.

104
00:13:07,310 --> 00:13:12,690
And the fact of the matter is that how is education and schooling being performed right now?

105
00:13:12,690 --> 00:13:13,770
It's in people's homes.

106
00:13:13,770 --> 00:13:22,410
So again, making sure that there's more money for E-Rate so that we can digitally connect with our youngest learners, including post-secondary.

107
00:13:22,690 --> 00:13:27,070
Lifeline and focusing on the low income has got to be an additional part of this dialogue.

108
00:13:27,070 --> 00:13:43,170
And then the third thing that I have really focused on with folks in Congress is making sure that there is some type of an affordable option that we are starting to think through as well in making sure that we have all houses connected.

109
00:13:43,170 --> 00:13:46,210
It's past time for us to connect all Americans.

110
00:13:46,210 --> 00:13:49,110
And Congress is going to have to help us out.

111
00:13:49,310 --> 00:13:50,690
Sure.

112
00:13:50,690 --> 00:14:08,030
So you started explaining the digital divide problem and then the prescriptions for solution by referencing the civil rights icon, John Lewis.

113
00:14:08,030 --> 00:14:23,750
And I will just note that that wonderful quote, access to the internet, is the civil rights issue of the 21st century, which you said is in fact, and it's timely and a little chilling the way that you all ended your op-ed.

114
00:14:23,750 --> 00:14:26,990
Yeah, I think that's exactly right.

115
00:14:27,070 --> 00:14:35,190
And when, you know, like I said, when John Lewis speaks, thank God so many people listen.

116
00:14:35,190 --> 00:14:45,890
And so that quote from John Lewis many, many years ago is what really kind of framed for me the ubiquity of broadband access being a civil right.

117
00:14:46,010 --> 00:14:54,390
And so, like I said, was proud to partner with so many leaders on focusing on how we actually make this thing start to happen.

118
00:14:54,390 --> 00:15:13,950
And in particular, like so many things that are going on right now, both in the pandemic and also in the racial justice, not only the moment, but the movement that we're seeing going on right now, and making sure that communities of color and the inequities that we see with regard to broadband are part of that focus.

119
00:15:14,290 --> 00:15:15,510
Sure.

120
00:15:15,630 --> 00:15:36,270
So if I may, I'd like to switch gears a bit and just reference the fact that there has been an ongoing debate about the extent to which the FCC has jurisdiction over cyber security, or at least some aspects of cyber security.

121
00:15:36,270 --> 00:15:39,070
There's different views on this.

122
00:15:39,070 --> 00:15:43,070
Can you sort of frame the contours of the debate for us?

123
00:15:43,070 --> 00:15:50,890
And let us in on what side of the debate or where along its continuum you fall?

124
00:15:51,070 --> 00:15:51,810
Sure, sure.

125
00:15:51,810 --> 00:15:52,150
Thank you.

126
00:15:52,150 --> 00:15:53,330
Great question.

127
00:15:53,330 --> 00:16:04,310
And so, you know, as you referenced in recent years, various commissioners have expressed different views about how involved the FCC should be in cyber security issues.

128
00:16:04,310 --> 00:16:10,210
During the Obama administration, I'd note, the FCC sought an active role in cyber security.

129
00:16:10,210 --> 00:16:15,450
And the current chairman, of course, I would note, has been much less involved.

130
00:16:15,450 --> 00:16:21,510
And so some of the differences fall on where people interpret our statutory authority.

131
00:16:21,510 --> 00:16:40,270
Some of my colleagues, Republican colleagues, feel strongly that we should very narrowly construe our instructions from Congress and, you know, only in a very limited scalpel-like way regulate cyber security when Congress expressly tells us to.

132
00:16:40,270 --> 00:16:43,650
I think that is too narrow a view.

133
00:16:43,730 --> 00:16:52,730
The Communication Act, in setting up the FCC's authority even long ago in 1934, said that it was creating the FCC.

134
00:16:52,730 --> 00:17:06,410
We were imbued in part for, you know, I quote, the purpose of the national defense, purpose of promoting safety and life and property, you know, close quote, if I'm memorizing it from memory.

135
00:17:06,470 --> 00:17:13,130
You know, and so I think we have a responsibility for modern networks to raise these kinds of concerns.

136
00:17:13,130 --> 00:17:15,930
And the FCC should have an active role.

137
00:17:15,930 --> 00:17:24,890
Some of the debate is practical moving on from some of the statutory, has been anointed with leadership, a leadership role here.

138
00:17:24,890 --> 00:17:30,870
And so again, some of my colleagues would shift all of that to DHS.

139
00:17:30,870 --> 00:17:40,830
And I think the FCC has valuable, essential, relevant expertise and experience that should come to bear here.

140
00:17:40,830 --> 00:17:44,970
And so pushing it all to somebody else, I think does us a disservice.

141
00:17:44,970 --> 00:17:54,030
And so, you know, I would also kind of briefly tick through what's going in my mind is, you know, a couple of the ways where we do have a role here.

142
00:17:54,030 --> 00:17:57,930
We evaluate license applications from foreign ownership.

143
00:17:57,930 --> 00:18:01,850
And this includes a national security review from team telecom.

144
00:18:01,850 --> 00:18:08,710
For some of your viewers who may know, cybersecurity is also part of the process of reviewing submarine cables.

145
00:18:08,710 --> 00:18:15,430
And this is a critical part of how we connect data and it's transmitted across the world.

146
00:18:15,430 --> 00:18:17,950
So there are cybersecurity elements there.

147
00:18:18,170 --> 00:18:24,130
And then something that I've really focused on, and that is removing untrustworthy equipment from our networks.

148
00:18:24,550 --> 00:18:44,170
And, you know, we at the FCC, you know, in large part, because I kind of called and beat the drum here, is focusing on removing this untrustworthy equipment where universal service fund, again, this is the fund that we administer at the FCC, making sure it's not used to purchase insecure equipment,

149
00:18:44,170 --> 00:18:49,030
Chinese equipment for Huawei ZTE, you know, I think are really important.

150
00:18:49,030 --> 00:18:56,030
And then the kind of the last thing that I would mention is, you know, we have the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement at CALEA.

151
00:18:56,030 --> 00:18:58,850
I know you have a DOJ background as well, Stephanie.

152
00:18:58,850 --> 00:19:12,530
And so CALEA, and this is also coming, you know, how we establish policies and procedures to prevent unauthorized surveillance is something that continues to kind of flare up.

153
00:19:12,530 --> 00:19:16,350
And I think it's something that we need to continue to have a voice in.

154
00:19:16,950 --> 00:19:20,570
And I do think that issue is not going away anytime soon.

155
00:19:21,210 --> 00:19:29,470
So let's say for the sake of argument that it's January 21st, 2021.

156
00:19:29,850 --> 00:19:32,650
And I don't have a crystal ball in front of me.

157
00:19:32,650 --> 00:19:46,610
But for the sake of argument, let's say there are now three, instead of two Democratic FCC commissioners, let's say there are three like minded Democratic FCC commissioners.

158
00:19:46,610 --> 00:19:52,510
And let's say you're incredibly influential among the three.

159
00:19:52,510 --> 00:20:06,610
So if you have that kind of clout and influence, what kind of cybersecurity focused initiatives or actions would you wish the commission to take?

160
00:20:06,690 --> 00:20:09,190
Well, I like the question.

161
00:20:09,410 --> 00:20:14,630
And I will say as well, I'm not in the prognostication business.

162
00:20:15,110 --> 00:20:26,330
And so I'll focus on what some of my priorities that I'm going to continue to be talking about, regardless of future administration.

163
00:20:26,690 --> 00:20:39,730
And so, you know, the first thing I would focus on is, like I said, I was the commissioner who has met the most with the small carriers who have insecure Huawei and ZTE equipment in their infrastructure.

164
00:20:39,730 --> 00:20:42,230
I came out with find it, fix it, fund it.

165
00:20:42,230 --> 00:20:48,590
That was we need to find insecure equipment, we need to fix it and remediate it, and then make sure we fund it.

166
00:20:48,590 --> 00:20:53,290
And so the last part of that is something that we still need to work with Congress on.

167
00:20:53,290 --> 00:20:55,070
And so that would be something that I would focus on.

168
00:20:55,070 --> 00:21:00,730
We have not appropriated funding for the repair and replacement part of that.

169
00:21:00,730 --> 00:21:12,810
As a result, you know, we do have some, you know, recipients who are lacking the funds to maintain their networks, even though we have already prohibited them from using Huawei ZTE.

170
00:21:12,810 --> 00:21:25,870
And so, you know, I would focus in, you know, in the future in January, on making sure we open up those lines of communication and have that better funding as well.

171
00:21:26,130 --> 00:21:33,330
You know, I think that has to be priority number one on a network security and cybersecurity kind of front.

172
00:21:33,330 --> 00:21:40,090
The second thing I would really focus on is, you know, kind of a vision board piece that I have been focusing on for a while now.

173
00:21:40,090 --> 00:21:52,910
And that is, you know, promoting network security as part of our communication network and development, and not proposing bandaid remedies, but really kind of being forward-looking.

174
00:21:52,910 --> 00:22:16,070
And where I really see this coming about is in our 5G future, and in particular, the Open Radio Access Network, or O-RAN, solutions, and making sure that we have, going forward, a real American role in the distribution and single system of interoperable hardware that emphasizes software,

175
00:22:16,070 --> 00:22:19,010
defined functions, open interfaces, cloud hierarchy.

176
00:22:19,010 --> 00:22:21,510
All of these are going to start to come together.

177
00:22:21,670 --> 00:22:37,430
And so from a networking standpoint, increasing efficiency, cost-effectiveness, you know, O-RAN is also going to provide the capability for scale and design improvements, updates at lower costs, faster timetable.

178
00:22:37,450 --> 00:22:41,870
And so we've got to continue to focus on this aspect of network security.

179
00:22:41,930 --> 00:22:59,130
And something that I've called for even most recently, just even as last month, is that especially when we're talking about in a rip-and-replace world, where we are, the American taxpayers are going to be rebuilding these networks for a lot of carriers.

180
00:22:59,130 --> 00:23:08,730
I think it is, I think it is time for us to make sure that some of those carriers hear from an O-RAN option.

181
00:23:08,730 --> 00:23:22,810
And so I think that's going to help promote it as a business case, as a product, and making sure that O-RAN really goes from what some in this administration have called pie in the sky, and really making sure that that O-RAN becomes part of our real world.

182
00:23:22,810 --> 00:23:26,770
I think it's going to be a part of American security going forward.

183
00:23:26,970 --> 00:23:35,070
The last thing that I would kind of be on my vision board is focusing on end-user device security.

184
00:23:35,110 --> 00:23:45,090
As I mentioned in particular with the digital divide, lifeline phones and providers often have low-cost devices.

185
00:23:45,090 --> 00:23:49,970
And so two common manufacturers of these low-cost devices are Huawei and ZTE.

186
00:23:50,370 --> 00:24:00,050
And so when you're talking about those devices, it's been revealed that sometimes they are embedded with malware, can be encrypted multiple times.

187
00:24:00,050 --> 00:24:05,890
And so some of the phone's settings and applications make it virtually impossible to uninstall.

188
00:24:05,890 --> 00:24:08,870
And so that's an issue that I have focused on.

189
00:24:08,870 --> 00:24:20,190
I think we need to make sure that the prices that people have around using to pay for a phone that's affordable is not compromised on some of these security and privacy issues.

190
00:24:20,190 --> 00:24:21,630
I think that's unacceptable.

191
00:24:21,790 --> 00:24:27,470
And because the commission has control over the lifeline program, I think we need to use that authority.

192
00:24:27,470 --> 00:24:33,310
We're obligated to make sure that the basic functionality here does keep our Americans secure.

193
00:24:33,310 --> 00:24:39,370
The last, last thing that I would mention that I've called for a number of times is internal changes at the FCC.

194
00:24:39,370 --> 00:24:43,130
We need to create a national security task force.

195
00:24:43,130 --> 00:24:54,130
The fact of the matter is that these network and national security issues and the cross-section that they have with our network issues have continued to come up.

196
00:24:54,130 --> 00:25:05,430
And we need to have a better, more collaborative way that we approach these issues rather than it being kind of whack-a-mole even at the FCC.

197
00:25:05,810 --> 00:25:08,430
Internal coordination has got to increase.

198
00:25:08,550 --> 00:25:13,470
We cannot have inconsistent treatment on these vital issues of national security.

199
00:25:13,530 --> 00:25:15,310
And again, these issues just aren't going to diminish.

200
00:25:15,310 --> 00:25:16,130
Quite the opposite.

201
00:25:16,130 --> 00:25:27,450
I think the complexity of these issues are going to only mean that we're going to have to step up more and deal with these with a cross-collaborative mindset.

202
00:25:28,110 --> 00:25:58,190
So, sort of to close out, it seems that you are very much focused not just on national security and privacy, but how the practices that we implement, those values, those outcomes, do not have disparate impacts on various communities.

203
00:25:58,190 --> 00:26:02,130
In other words, this needs to be a holistic approach.

204
00:26:02,130 --> 00:26:18,250
And frankly, you are an advocate, it sounds like, for the FCC playing an important role at addressing these issues in a holistic way and specifically in a way that does not have a disparate impact on communities of color.

205
00:26:18,250 --> 00:26:20,650
I could not agree more.

206
00:26:20,650 --> 00:26:39,050
And the fact of the matter is that so many of these issues, when you're talking about network issues and cybersecurity issues and privacy issues, so many of these are intertwined and commingled in ways that I think the FCC has a real role and a real voice to play.

207
00:26:39,050 --> 00:26:55,290
When I look at some of the surveillance issues, when I look at some of the AI issues, some of the algorithmic bias issues, a lot of these are having a disproportionate impact on communities of color, on the marginalized, on the most vulnerable.

208
00:26:55,290 --> 00:27:15,330
And so, I'm going to continue to use my voice and use my platform to make sure that these are issues that have a spotlight shine, and we're working through them with policy, and we're making sure that there is equity and digital equity that is brought to bear on a lot of these issues.

209
00:27:15,330 --> 00:27:21,410
So, could not agree more on that proposition.

210
00:27:21,950 --> 00:27:35,510
Well, Commissioner Starks, again, I promised your staff that I would keep time on this and not make you late for your next Zoom or call, if you will.

211
00:27:35,550 --> 00:27:36,090
Yes.

212
00:27:36,090 --> 00:27:37,390
Thank you.

213
00:27:37,390 --> 00:27:40,430
Thank you so much for your time.

214
00:27:41,150 --> 00:27:52,410
You know, hopefully, we'll be in a very different situation as a nation and as a world next year, and we can continue the conversation in person in Vegas.

215
00:27:52,410 --> 00:27:53,630
I'll look forward to it.

216
00:27:53,630 --> 00:27:54,830
Always good to talk to you, Stephanie.

217
00:27:54,830 --> 00:27:55,490
Thank you so much.

218
00:27:55,490 --> 00:27:56,330
Be well.

219
00:27:57,390 --> 00:27:58,070
Thank you.

220
00:27:58,070 --> 00:27:58,810
Bye-bye.